Defining the Moment: When Does Copyright Infringement Actually Occur?
Whether you're a content creator, marketer, in any kind of business, or just online, it's crucial to understand the concept of copyright.
We often see YouTubers and creators on platforms like Instagram and TikTok take video content, watermarked photos and licensed music to use in their own content without a second thought.
However, this is not actually legal, and using copyrighted content can get you in a lot of trouble - ranging from being permantently banned by a social media platform (YouTube’s infamous “3 strikes and you’re out” rule), to actually be sent to jail.
Penalties vary from state to state, but it can reach up to 10 years of jail time and potentially millions of dollars in fines, depending on how much of a work and how many times it was copied illegally.
To help keep you and your business safe, in this guide, we'll be exploring the question: "When does copyright infringement actually occur?"
We'll be diving into the fundamentals of copyright, defining infringement, and providing examples that highlight the fine line separating legal use from copyright violations.
The Basics of Copyright
Copyright is a legal concept that grants exclusive rights to the creator of original works in various domains, such as literary, artistic, dramatic, musical, or architectural creations. It even covers computer software!
This protection is provided by national law and international conventions to ensure that creators can control how their work is used and distributed, as well as receive economic benefits from its usage.
The moment a work is created, it is automatically protected by copyright, regardless of whether it bears any explicit copyrighted symbols.
While the extra step of registering a copyright in a country’s copyright office is not mandatory, it can considerably strengthen a creator's legal standing in case disputes arise, and provide an easier path to recover damages or legal fees.
Some critical aspects that copyright covers include:
Reproduction of the work
Distribution of copies
Public performance
Public display
Creation of derivative works
It's essential to recognize that copyright protects the expression of an idea, not the idea itself.
This means that while the tangible output of an idea (writing, painting, photograph, etc.) can be copyrighted, the idea behind it cannot.
Defining Copyright Infringement
Copyright infringement occurs when someone uses copyrighted material without obtaining permission from the copyright holder and goes beyond the limits set by exceptions like "Fair Use."
Infringement can take several forms, including but not limited to:
Unauthorized reproduction of copyrighted works;
Unauthorized distribution or sale of copyrighted works;
Unauthorized public performances or displays of copyrighted materials; and
Creation of derivative works based on copyrighted materials without permission.
It's important to note that copyright infringement can happen inadvertently, even without malicious intent.
For instance, if a person shares a photograph taken by a professional photographer without permission, they may infringe on the photographer's copyright.
This can be all it takes. Even posting a video with a copyrighted song playing in the background can be enough for some kind of penalty action to be taken.
The Fine Line: When Does Copyright Infringement Occur?
Identifying when copyright infringement occurs can be challenging, especially when the use of copyrighted materials seems harmless or falls into a legal gray area.
To provide some clarity, let's consider a few practical examples to help illustrate the boundaries between permissible use and infringement:
Sharing quotes from a book
Quoting a small portion of a copyrighted literary work for educational purposes or as a reference may be permissible and not considered infringement under the Fair Use exception. However, copying a significant part of the work and sharing it without permission or credit would likely be considered an infringement. In a number of “education copyright cases” the key issue ended up being “did the teacher copy so much of the book into a handout that it deprived the author of the book from an actual sale of the book itself?”
Using copyrighted images on a website
Using copyrighted images without proper permission or licensing on your website would be considered copyright infringement. To avoid this, you must obtain permission from the copyright holder or use images available in the public domain or covered by open licenses like Creative Commons.
Creating a cover of a song without permission
While adapting a copyrighted song into a new arrangement or your rendition may seem harmless, creating a cover without the copyright holder's consent could also constitute infringement.
Disputes over copyright infringement often require case-by-case analysis, as the line between what constitutes permissible use and infringement can be subjective and varies depending on numerous factors.
Understanding "Fair Use"
Okay, fair use. I've spoken about it a little, but we must spend some proper time with it.
"Fair Use" is a critical doctrine within copyright law that allows specific uses of copyrighted materials without the copyright owner's permission. It promotes creativity, comment, criticism, education, and the development of new ideas. While the concept of "Fair Use" can vary among different legal systems, it generally takes into account the following 4 factors:
The purpose and character of the use, including whether it is for commercial or non-profit/educational purposes;
The nature of the copyrighted work;
The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
The effect of the use on the potential market or value of the copyrighted work.
Some common "Fair Use" examples include:
Criticism or review: A film critic using portions of a movie to discuss its merits or flaws.
Education: Teachers using very small excerpts from copyrighted works to support teaching materials that compare writing styles of different modern authors.
Parody: A comedy sketch that reimagines a well-known song in a humorous way.
It's important to remember that "Fair Use" is a defense that can be utilized in cases of alleged copyright infringement, and these exceptions don't grant open permission to freely use copyrighted materials.
Evaluating whether a specific situation qualifies as "Fair Use" typically requires a thorough analysis of the use aligns with the 4 factors .
How to Avoid Crossing the Line into Copyright Infringement
Avoiding copyright infringement might feel like navigating a minefield, but with a few precautions and guidelines, it can be effectively managed:
Seek Permission: The most crucial step in avoiding copyright infringement is to seek and obtain permission from the copyright owner before using their work, whether to reproduce, distribute, perform, or create derivatives.
Look for Open Licenses or Public Domain Works: Many creators are willing to share their works under open licenses like Creative Commons, or the works may be in the public domain. Such works offer more flexibility for use but still require adherence to the license terms or regulations governing public domain materials.
Invoke Fair Use Doctrine Judiciously: While "Fair Use" can provide certain leeways within copyright law, its application can be subjective and complicated. Evaluate whether your intended use aligns with "Fair Use" principles carefully, and when in doubt, seek legal advice. Remember - Fair Use is a only defense to copyright infringement - the presumption is that copying is illegal infringement, you will have the obligation to prove you fall within the narrow defense and should not be punished.
What to Do If Your Work Has Been Infringed Upon
Navigating the situation when your copyright is infringed upon can be challenging. However, there are several courses of action you can consider:
Open Communication: As a first step, try contacting the infringing party. Discussing it directly can often resolve minor misunderstandings or accidental infringement cases.
Cease and Desist Letter: If the infringement persists and is blatant, you could consider sending a cease and desist letter (either on your own or through a legal representative) to demand that the infringing party stop using your material.
DMCA Takedown Notices: A Digital Millennium Copyright (DMCA) takedown notice can be issued to remove infringing materials on internet platforms.
Legal Action: You can pursue a copyright lawsuit when all else fails. Consult with a lawyer to understand your chances of success and the potential benefits versus costs involved.
Conclusion
Understanding when copyright infringement occurs and how to avoid it can be a potential minefield, but with a cautious approach and thorough understanding of copyright law, it's possible to navigate it effectively.
I hope this guide helps you understand the nuances of copyright law and the distinction between lawful use and copyright infringement, whether you're a content creator or user.
For more guidance in these areas, please follow us on our social media platforms or sign up for our newsletter.
